Thinking of Switching to Capture One from Lightroom? Here’s what you need to know.
I’ve been covering Capture One for a while here on the blog, and it seems that there is more and more interest of late. However, often when I do cover it, I get comments or mail from people who complain that it doesn’t have this feature or that feature, and some are upset with me for not pointing this out. So I thought I would try and do as comprehensive as possible, a comparison between Lightroom ad Capture one, listing the pros and cons of each, as well as why I like it so much.
This is mostly about Capture One Pro, and not the Express version.
I’ve been using Capture One since version 7. It’s now on version 12. In that time, I’ve gone from finding it interesting, but nothing special, to really appreciating the power under the hood of the software. It’s also changed significantly in that time. The company has added more and more features. It started off as a fairly specialised tool, but it’s now a very good general purpose editor.
It’s not Lightroom, though.
And this is the thing that I think trips a lot of people up. Capture One is not attempting to be a Lightroom clone, like On1 Raw or Alien Skin Exposure is. It’s interface and way of working is very different. Some people try the software, expecting it to behave the same way that Lightroom does, and are confused and disappointed. If anything the software is more like Apple’s Aperture, so if you’re coming from that you may find it more familiar.
This has led to the infamous “steep learning curve” that people like to say about the software. I’m not sure that is necessarily fair. If you approach the software from scratch, you can get the basics of it pretty quickly, but if you try to use it the way you would use Lightroom, then yes, I can imagine it would be difficult.
There’s also a lot to the software. While it lacks some key features that Lightroom has, it has many more features that Lightroom doesn’t have. There’s also often many ways to accomplish a task, and there are quite a few technical tools in it too.
The Big User Interface Differences
Apart from some of the features missing (more on that below), the big difference between the two applications is the fact that Capture One is modeless. In Lightroom, you have different modules for different functions, and you switch between modules. Each module is a separate sub section of the software, and loads one at a time.
In Capture One, all parts of the software are active all the time. There are no separate modules. The interface is divided into tabs, but this is just a way to organise it so it’s not too cluttered. The interface is also fully customisable, so you can actually rearrange it however you want. You could put everything into a single line of panels if you wanted to.
The second big difference is that Capture One uses tools. Lightroom doesn’t really use a tool interface, but Capture One does. Think of this as being like the way Photoshop has tools. There is a lot of functionality in these tools too, so if you’re used to just using sliders and buttons to work with your images, you may find this approach confusing at first, but it’s just a matter of getting used to it.
What’s missing (the Cons of Capture One)
There are a few key features that Lightroom has that Capture One doesn’t. Top of this list is HDR merging, Panorama Merging , and any equivalent of the book and maps modules. It also lacks facial recognition. It is essentially a Raw developer and an asset management application without the bells and whistles. If you rely on these core features as a vital part of your workflow, then Capture One won’t be for you. There are workarounds for most of these though.
For HDR merging, I use Aurora HDR. You could also use Photoshop. For panorama merging, there’s also the option to use Photoshop, and on the Mac version of Capture One, there is a script to merge images in Photoshop. For books, theres Blurb’s own book creation software.
Incidentally, if you have a Panorama that you merged in Lightroom, the DNG will work fine in Capture One. It doesn’t currently support the HDR DNGs though.
There’s also a few other differences. Capture One supports most lenses through its lens correction module, but there are some differences, and Lightroom probably has a larger database. Some features are also limited by the camera too.
Another feature lacking is any equivalent of the history palette. You do have multiple undos, but you don’t get to see your complete history as you do in Lightroom. You can of course create multiple versions (called “Variants” in Capture One’s language”)
There are also less plug-ins available for Capture One. They only just added a proper plug-in API and so far the support for this has been limited. You can get around this limitation by round-tripping to Photoshop to se your favourite plug-ins, but if you rely on a specific add-on, then this may be a deal breaker for you.
There are a few things that are a bit quirky in Capture One that may throw people. The previews system is a bit odd, and confuses people. It can sometimes be a bit soft, and it also takes up more space than Lightroom’s previews, but it’s also doing something akin to Lightroom’s smart previews, and you can unlink your images and still work with them. I have a video about this which explains the issue and how to work around it.
The copy and paste interface can be a bit confusing too, but again, this is because there are lots of different ways of doing the same thing. You can simply copy and paste adjustments, by using a keyboard shortcut, in much the same way as you do with Lightroom, but you can also copy individual panels and apply those. On top of that there is a function called apply - which works similarly to Lightroom’s syncing. This is again available on a per-adjustment basis or on the whole image. The interface for this is a tad confusing though, it has to be said.
The other odd thing is that there is no easy keyboard shortcut for before and after view. For baffling reasons, this functionality was only added a few versions ago, and to view before and after images you need to hold down the option key while clicking and holding on the reset button. This confuses new users, but it’s not a big deal once you get used to it.
Why I Like Capture One - The Pros
As I mentioned in the previous section, there are a some features missing, and its mostly a Raw converter and asset manager. But these key areas actually pack a lot of functionality and are very powerful, especially the processing side. I’m not going to cover every single feature, as we’d be here all day, but rather cover some of my favourite things about the software.
1. The colour editing tools
The options and controls for editing colours in Capture One is very powerful. First there is the Colour Balance tool. This is a three way colour corrector, which is similar to the toolset used for colour grading video. It allows you to control the colour and brightness of the shadows, mid tones and highlights separately. You can actually do a surprising amount of your colour editing in this tool alone.
Second is the Colour Editor. This is like Lightroom HSL colour controls only much more powerful. You can control the range of a particular shade, and you can add as many individual colour keys as you want and adjust those separately. And then you can save all of these as a custom colour profile if you want. You can also use the keyed colours to generate a layer mask and use that for further manipulation.
Speaking of colour profiles, one of the other useful features is that you can use any colour profile from any camera - you’re not locked to a particular module. I have also found that for certain cameras, the colour profiles are much better than Lightroom’s versions. This is especially true for Sony cameras for some reason. (This is more a weakness of Lightroom mind you).
This is a fairly recent addition to the software, but it has become extremely powerful. It has evolved from Capture One’s selective editing toolset, and you can now stack adjustment layers, each with their own masks which can be gradient, radial gradient or just painted). Layers can contain most of the adjustments in the software (although not all) and you get a clear visual interface for the layers and you can rename them and reorder them. You can also control the opacity of layers, so you can use this to blend two different styles for example.
Layers can also be cloning or healing layers, and you can use these for removing objects etc. You can also generate a luma-mask for layers or use the colour editors keyed to generate a mask. This can be useful to do things like, apply more noise reduction in the shadows for example. While Lightroom can do some of these things in the selective editing toolset, it’s not as visual or as clearly laid out, and in my opinion, Capture One’s layers are much more powerful.
3. Multiple Simultaneous Output
As I mentioned earlier, the export functionality of Capture One can be a bit confusing with its multitude of options, but it has one really powerful and useful feature.
You can set up multiple export “recipes” (called “Process Recipes”) which are similar to Lightroom’s export presets. However, you can turn multiple process recipes at once and have Capture One export multiple versions of your image simultaneously. For example, you can have it export a full res Tiff for your archives, a scaled version with a watermark for your website, and an even smaller version for social media, all at the same time.
What’s more, the recipes themselves can use “tokens” for various things like folder and file names. These tokens are basically variables taken from the metadata of the image being exported, so you can have it generate sub folders based on camera name for example, or any other metadata - including keywords and so on. This makes the export system very powerful.
4. Ability to save individual adjustment panel presets
Capture One uses different terminology for what Lightroom calls “Presets”. The equivalent of develop module presets in Capture One are called “Styles”. However there is also a separate feature called “presets”. Presets are used to store settings for individual adjustment panels. They appear int he drop down menu of each panel, and you can save settings for most panels and they will appear here. This is a huge time saver and once you get used to it, it’s a really great feature.
5. The Little Things
There’s a lot of little things too that I like about Capture One over Lightroom. These include:
- Levels tool
- Multiple options for Clarity - which are more natural looking than Lightroom’s version
- Structure - which is like a finer version of Clarity
- Grain tool has more options than Lightroom’s version
- Separate Luma and RGB curves
- Shadow and Highlight recovery seems to have less halo issues than Lightroom’s versions.
- Halo Suppression on the sharpening controls.
- Sharpness falloff correction for lenses on the lens correction panel.
Should you use it?
As I keep saying on this blog, the only person that can decide that is you. There is a trial version of Capture One available, and the best way to figure out if its for you or not, is to give it a go. Everyone has their own views, opinions and needs, and while I really like the software you may not, and that’s ok.
If you do fid the software confusing, I do have an overview video. This was originally made for the express version, so it misses many of the features mentioned here, and it’s for an older version, but it also is a good way to get your head around the interface quickly. You can find it on my YouTube channel and I’ll embed it below too.
As I mentioned in the article, this only really scratches the surface. If you have any questions please ask in the comments below and I’ll do my best to answer when I can.
Help Support the Blog
This blog is pretty much my day job now and I work to bring you my own take on photography, both tutorials and tips, as well as inspiration from my own art. I support this work, and my YouTube channel entirely either via sales of my eBooks and Lightroom presets, or the kind support of my readers. (I also have some affiliate ads). Running all this isn’t cheap, and so If you like what you see and you want to help keep this all going, there are a number of ways you can do so:
- If you’re interested in buying Capture One but haven’t yet bought your own copy yet, then by going through my affiliate link I’ll get a small commission!
- You can buy any of my Capture One Styles through my online store!
- If you’re buying anything on Amazon, you can help by using my affiliate link: Amazon US or Amazon UK.
- You can support me on Patreon. If you like what I do here and find the information useful, then you can help by subscribing to me on Patreon. As well as helping keep this blog going with even more useful news, tips, tutorials and more, members also get special Patreon only feed, which gives you behind the scenes content, as well as monthly downloads (for the top tier), for only €2 or €5 a month Stop by and check it out.
- Buy me a coffee / Tip Jar. If you want to support the blog but don't want to sign up for Patreon, you can buy me a coffee via PayPal with a one off donation to my PayPal tip jar.
You can see more of my photography and keep up to date by following me on social media and checking out my other websites: